Jump to content

Cobre Panamá/Who decides: Difference between revisions

From Wiki
Cobre Panamá: illustrative model
 
Cobre Panamá: illustrative model
 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{DISPLAYTITLE:Who decides, and what people think}}
''Illustrative model. Spektrum built this site from published sources to show how a Development by Consent process about the future of the Cobre Panamá mine could work. No such process has been agreed: not by the Government of Panama, not by First Quantum Minerals, and not by any community. Nothing here speaks for them.''
''Illustrative model. Spektrum built this site from published sources to show how a Development by Consent process about the future of the Cobre Panamá mine could work. No such process has been agreed: not by the Government of Panama, not by First Quantum Minerals, and not by any community. Nothing here speaks for them.''



Latest revision as of 12:21, 17 November 2026

Illustrative model. Spektrum built this site from published sources to show how a Development by Consent process about the future of the Cobre Panamá mine could work. No such process has been agreed: not by the Government of Panama, not by First Quantum Minerals, and not by any community. Nothing here speaks for them.

The future of the mine is undecided. This page sets out who has a say under the present arrangements and what opinion polls have found.

The Government

The President said in January 2026 that a decision would come in June (Minería en Línea). In June 2026 he named the ministers of Environment, Economy and Commerce to a technical commission on the question (La Prensa). The decision has since been put back while the audit is reviewed and the risks of arbitration are assessed (Panama Times).

The courts

The Supreme Court's ruling of November 2023 stands: the contract was unconstitutional (Eco Jurisprudence Monitor).

A referendum

A referendum was announced in 2023 (CIAR Global), and the Electoral Tribunal said it could not hold one (Energiminas). In a poll published on 23 July 2026, 68.7 percent of those asked supported holding a referendum to decide the future of mining (Destino Panamá).

Opinion polls

Polls in 2026 do not agree with one another:

  • A poll by Prodigious Consulting found 64.9 percent against reopening the mine and 29.9 percent in favour (La Estrella de Panamá).
  • A poll published on 23 July 2026 found 66.4 percent against reopening (Destino Panamá).
  • A poll by Doxa found 50 percent in favour of reopening (Destino Panamá).

Civil society

In June 2025, 101 international civil society organisations wrote to First Quantum asking it to drop its arbitration against Panama and to remedy environmental damage at the site (MiningWatch Canada).

What a consent process adds

A poll counts opinions on one day. A court decides what the law allows. Neither asks the people most affected what conditions they would set, or records an answer they can hold anyone to. That is the gap a process like the one modelled here is meant to fill.

Cobre Panamá