Cobre Panamá/Water and tailings: Difference between revisions
Cobre Panamá: illustrative model |
Cobre Panamá: illustrative model |
||
| (One intermediate revision by the same user not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{DISPLAYTITLE:Water and tailings}} | |||
''Illustrative model. Spektrum built this site from published sources to show how a Development by Consent process about the future of the Cobre Panamá mine could work. No such process has been agreed: not by the Government of Panama, not by First Quantum Minerals, and not by any community. Nothing here speaks for them.'' | ''Illustrative model. Spektrum built this site from published sources to show how a Development by Consent process about the future of the Cobre Panamá mine could work. No such process has been agreed: not by the Government of Panama, not by First Quantum Minerals, and not by any community. Nothing here speaks for them.'' | ||
| Line 7: | Line 8: | ||
== What independent experts engaged by civil society say == | == What independent experts engaged by civil society say == | ||
In December 2024 experts of the Environmental Law Alliance Worldwide said, in a preliminary report, that the tailings dam was at very serious and imminent risk of failure because of internal erosion and a lack of proper monitoring ([https://miningwatch.ca/news/2024/12/12/experts-say-first-quantums-cobre-panama-tailings-dam-very-serious-and-imminent-risk MiningWatch Canada | In December 2024 experts of the Environmental Law Alliance Worldwide said, in a preliminary report, that the tailings dam was at very serious and imminent risk of failure because of internal erosion and a lack of proper monitoring ([https://miningwatch.ca/news/2024/12/12/experts-say-first-quantums-cobre-panama-tailings-dam-very-serious-and-imminent-risk MiningWatch Canada (ELAW)]). | ||
== What people living nearby say == | == What people living nearby say == | ||
Latest revision as of 12:21, 17 November 2026
Illustrative model. Spektrum built this site from published sources to show how a Development by Consent process about the future of the Cobre Panamá mine could work. No such process has been agreed: not by the Government of Panama, not by First Quantum Minerals, and not by any community. Nothing here speaks for them.
Tailings are the ground rock and water left after copper is removed from ore. At Cobre Panamá they are stored behind a dam. Whether that dam is safe, and whether water around the mine is clean, are disputed. This page sets out who says what.
What the company says
First Quantum says the designs of its tailings facility conform to the bulletins of the International Commission on Large Dams and follow recognised good practice (First Quantum Minerals). Cobre Panamá's sustainability report for 2024 says independent international experts confirmed the good state of the facility in an audit in 2024 and a review in 2025 (Cobre Panamá (Minera Panamá S.A.)). The company has committed to align all its tailings facilities with the Global Industry Standard on Tailings Management by the end of 2030 (First Quantum Minerals). It publishes dam safety inspection and audit reports on a transparency page (Cobre Panamá (Minera Panamá S.A.)).
What independent experts engaged by civil society say
In December 2024 experts of the Environmental Law Alliance Worldwide said, in a preliminary report, that the tailings dam was at very serious and imminent risk of failure because of internal erosion and a lack of proper monitoring (MiningWatch Canada (ELAW)).
What people living nearby say
A member of Guerreros del Mar, an organisation of affected communities, said that contaminated tailings were filtering into groundwater connected to the headwaters of rivers that sustain thousands of residents of the district of Donoso (Earthworks). A resident of the Caimito Indigenous community told reporters that water sources had been affected and species were disappearing (Mongabay).
What the State's audit says
The comprehensive audit gave a rating of 81.70 percent for risks and future environmental liabilities, the lowest of its headings (Newsroom Panama). See The comprehensive audit.
The stockpiled ore
The company says that leaving mined ore stored on site for a long time carries a risk of acid rock drainage, and gives this as one reason for processing it (First Quantum Minerals). See Stockpiled ore and preservation.
What is not settled
These accounts do not agree. A process of this kind would put the monitoring data, the dam safety reports and the experts' findings side by side, in public, for the people who live downstream to question.